AI · Product design · Product management · Unusual AI

How scoring works

Interest + Innovation

Two scores out of 10

Every story gets two scores out of 10. The overall score is their average.

Interest: would a product designer or product manager stop and change something they do because of this?

Innovation: is this a new capability or approach, or a version of something that already exists?

ScoreWhat it means
10Changes how the work is done. A few a year.
8–9Clearly new and useful now. About one 9 a week at most.
6–7Worth knowing about.
4–5Incremental. Cut.
0–3Noise. Cut.

How a story gets in

  1. Scouts search the day's news for each topic, starting from primary sources and from the communities where builders talk.
  2. A separate checker opens every source, confirms the date and every number, and adds the original source when only coverage was found. Anything it can't confirm is dropped.
  3. Three judges score the checked stories side by side: a product designer, a product manager and a sceptical editor. Each story gets the median of their scores.
  4. Anything under 6 is cut. Each topic gets at least one story when something in it scores 6 or more, and the rest go by score. A quiet topic stays empty rather than padded.

Every Sunday I review the week's picks and adjust what the scouts look for.