Two scores out of 10
Every story gets two scores out of 10. The overall score is their average.
Interest: would a product designer or product manager stop and change something they do because of this?
Innovation: is this a new capability or approach, or a version of something that already exists?
| Score | What it means |
|---|---|
| 10 | Changes how the work is done. A few a year. |
| 8–9 | Clearly new and useful now. About one 9 a week at most. |
| 6–7 | Worth knowing about. |
| 4–5 | Incremental. Cut. |
| 0–3 | Noise. Cut. |
How a story gets in
- Scouts search the day's news for each topic, starting from primary sources and from the communities where builders talk.
- A separate checker opens every source, confirms the date and every number, and adds the original source when only coverage was found. Anything it can't confirm is dropped.
- Three judges score the checked stories side by side: a product designer, a product manager and a sceptical editor. Each story gets the median of their scores.
- Anything under 6 is cut. Each topic gets at least one story when something in it scores 6 or more, and the rest go by score. A quiet topic stays empty rather than padded.
Every Sunday I review the week's picks and adjust what the scouts look for.